I will try to simplify the speed limits as best I can, but to begin with:
We will start with the maximum passage time allowed to transit the Land Cut section of the Cape Cod Canal since it is the simplest to explain. You can think of maximum passage time as being the minimum speed that you are allowed during transit.
"Vessels of any kind unable to make a transit through the Land Cut portion of the canal against a head current of 6.0 knots within a maximum time limit of 2 hours 30 minutes shall be required to obtain the assistance of a helper tug at the vessel owner’s expense or await favorable tide [sic] conditions. . ."
Note: there is no maximum passage time defined for the Hog Island Channel portion of the canal, only the Land Cut.
Simply put, your vessel must be able to travel the 5.9 NM Land Cut section of the Cape Cod Canal in 2½ hours against a 6 knot opposing current.
What happens if you can’t maintain the required speed while transiting the canal?
"In the event vessels within the confines of the canal fail to perform and are unable to make sufficient headway against the currents, the marine traffic controller may activate a helper tug to assist."
I will let you take a guess on who pays for that!
With the Land Cut only being 5.9 NM, this normally would only require a speed of approximately 2.4 knots through the water in a no current situation. The problem is the “6 knot foul current requirement.” When you factor that in, then:
Your vessel needs to be able to make a minimum of 8.4 knots through the water
In order to meet the maximum time requirement. This effectively restricts the passage of most sailboats and many trawlers to times of more favorable current conditions.
(This can be interpreted as the maximum speed allowed for any vessel.)
To begin, it is best to think of the "Minimum Passage Time" as the maximum speed authorized when transiting the Cape Cod Canal.
Because current velocities are constantly changing with time and location, the chances of a single answer would be correct for the entire passage are pretty slim. A series of continuous calculations and speed adjustments would generally be required to hit the exact minimum transit time allowed as you pass through the canal.
The most common sense approach is to solve the maximum speed problem based on the average maximum currents that can be expected to be encountered. To further simplify the solution we will consider this average over the entire length of each section of the canal. So, while our answer will be close it will not be exact.
From the NOAA Tidal Current Tables we can identify and extract the average maximum current velocities for the (7) current stations located in the canal and its approaches:
Current Station | Avg. Maximum Flood Velocity |
Avg. Maximum Ebb Velocity |
---|---|---|
Abiels Ledge (Hog Island Channel) | 1.3 knots | 1.8 knots |
Hog Neck (Hog Island Channel) | 3.4 knots | 3.0 knots |
CCC Railroad Bridge (Land Cut) | 4.0 knots | 4.5 knots |
Bourne Highway Bridge (Land Cut) | 3.3 knots | 4.0 knots |
Bournedale (Land Cut) | 3.2 knots | 3.7 knots |
Sagamore Bridge (Land Cut) | 3.6 knots | 3.7 knots |
CCC East End (Land Cut) | 3.4 knots | 3.3 knots |
From this we can calculate the average maximum current velocities for the entire length of Hog Island Channel and also the entire length of the Land Cut portion of the Cape Cod Canal as shown in blue below.
Current Station | Avg. Maximum Flood Velocity |
Avg. Maximum Ebb Velocity |
---|---|---|
Land Cut Max. Velocity Averages | 3.50 knots | 3.84 knots |
Hog Island Channel Max. Velocity Averages | 2.40 knots | 2.40 knots |
We now have all the information we need to do the Time, Distance, & Speed calculations (T = D/S) to determine the maximum speed that we are allowed when transiting the canal.
Hog Island Channel East Bound |
Hog Island Channel West Bound |
|||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Current | Min. Transit Time | Distance | Required SOG |
Current | Required Boat Speed |
Required SOG |
Current | Required Boat Speed |
Fair Current | 23 Minutes | 4.7 NM | 12.3 Knots | 2.4 Knots | 9.9 knots | 12.3 Knots | 2.4 Knots | 9.9 Knots |
Slack Water | 35 Minutes | 4.7 NM | 8.1 Knots | 0.0 Knots | 8.1 Knots | 8.1 Knots | 0.0 Knots | 8.1 Knots |
Foul Current | 46 Minutes | 4.7 NM | 6.1 Knots | 2.4 Knots | 8.5 Knots | 6.1 Knots | 2.4 Knots | 8.5 Knots |
Cape Cod Canal East Bound |
Cape Cod Canal West Bound |
|||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Current | Min. Transit Time | Distance | Required SOG |
Current | Required Boat Speed |
Required SOG |
Current | Required Boat Speed |
Fair Current | 30 Minutes | 5.9 NM | 8.2 Knots | 3.5 Knots | 4.7 knots | 8.2 Knots | 3.8 Knots | 4.4 Knots |
Slack Water | 45 Minutes | 5.9 NM | 7.9 Knots | 0.0 Knots | 7.9 Knots | 7.9 Knots | 0.0 Knots | 7.9 Knots |
Foul Current | 60 Minutes | 5.9 NM | 5.9 Knots | 3.8 Knots | 9.7 Knots | 5.9 Knots | 3.5 Knots | 9.4 Knots |
As shown in the table above in "Bold," you now have a close idea of the maximum "average" speeds authorized to transit the canal.
In a couple of "unofficial" conversations with canal control, transiting the CCC at higher speeds was discussed, the consensus seemed to be that regardless of the current, as long as you are not carrying a large sea behind you, rarely is anything said as long as you keep your speed reasonable for the existing conditions. Just remember, that it is the "USACE" that gets to decide what is reasonable; not you.
Obviously, timing the currents is pretty much mandatory for low powered vessels and would benefit even faster vessels with fuel savings. So when is the best time to make the CCC passage?
The key here is to be looking for Slack Water Flood Begins (SWF.) Due to the fact that the Flood starts from the eastern end of the canal, if you time your passage for the exact time of SWF there is a possibility that you could out run the fair current. This is especially true for higher speed vessels, but could happen to even low powered vessels during times of higher than normal current velocities.
To provide your best opportunity for a fair current eastbound passage the window would begin about 20 minutes after SWF for low powered vessels and 1 hour after SWF for vessels capable of higher speeds.
To truly maximize the fair current you may want to consider timing your passage for 3½ hours after SWF.
Here you will be looking for Slack Water Ebb Begins (SWE). Like the flood, the ebb begins on the eastern end of the canal and builds to the west although over a much smaller time period. In fact there is only a 12 minute difference between either end of the Land Cut section of the canal.
Entering the canal westbound about 5 minutes after SWE for low powered vessels and 20 minutes after for faster vessels will give you the best odds for a fair current passage.
Entering westbound between 2½ and 2¾ hours after SWE should result in taking advantage of the maximum fair current velocities.